Question about Robustness
Consider a large scale-free network with average degree ⟨k⟩ = 5. According to robustness concepts, which of the following options best describes the critical fraction of nodes that would need to be removed to cause the collapse of the giant component (i) in the case of random failures and (ii) in the case of targeted attack, respectively? a) The network is equally robust to random failures and to attacks on hubs: in both cases, it is necessary to remove about 50% of the nodes to collapse the giant component. b) Under random failures, the network collapses after removing only about 15% of the nodes; in contrast, a targeted attack requires removing about 80% of the nodes (including the hubs) to fragment the giant component. c) In random failures, it is necessary to remove about 80% of the nodes to eliminate the giant component; in targeted attacks (removing hubs), removing about 15% of the nodes is enough to drastically fragment the network. d) There is no critical threshold for random f...